Too Much Technology in the Classroom?? (A response to an Article)

While hunting for articles related to technology and its effects on the classroom, I came across this article from the BBC...which I felt had a lot of relevance to issues that are occurring here in the states as well. It got me to thinking more and more about technology and whether it's doing harm or good when it comes to integration in the classroom.

The article grabbed my attention right off the bat.

"There was a time when teachers stood in front of the class, with chalk poised on the blackboard while pupils scribbled away furiously. Now teachers' presentations have to compete with the expectations raised by the technology children have at home - iPods, Playstations and home computers."

Being someone who has really been immersed in technology from day one - this really rang true in my brain. While I have never actually been in a classroom solely dedicated to blackboards and chalk, I can see how teachers are now competing with technologies. To gain a child's attention takes a lot of effort...especially when they are immersed in their iPods, and cell phones...let alone a computer or video game. It made me respect the teachers who have gotten through that mess and had an impact on me as a student. While I was brought up without the video games, the iPods, and cell phones (up until I was in college)...a lot of my classmates had these items. And looking back on how that effected me...I would say that some time was given on the teachers part to grab the attention of my peers.

The plus side of technology integration was also talked about in this article... (As said by Steve Powter, quoted in the article.)

"Rather than sitting behind desks and looking at a piece of paper, the pupils can play with things on screen and move things around. The kids are used to it. They walk into a room and if the white board has something written on it they follow it instantly."

TRUE - but this brings up a point in my mind. Attention spans of children these day tend to be less and less by my observation (people can feel free to disagree with me here). Can you really maintain a child's attention by keeping things technology integrated?? Is there a point where good old fashion teaching (without technology) has an impact on these students as well??

As a known fact, the costs of technology are rising all the time...and a lot of schools have a hard time keeping up with technologies that are changing so frequently. I think that if technology were more affordable there would be a lot of teachers who could afford and would take the time to learn them and possibly integrate them more into the classroom. I'm sure that things will change over time...but right now...I think for some schools it's a struggle to overcome the issues that come with technology integration.

Student's Needs...

The reading from our text this week was actually incredibly informative...so I thought I would put a few thoughts down here so that I can refer back to them at a later date...

1. Addressing patters of students needs to benefit many learners (pg. 97-99)

When I first saw this diagram, my reaction was "what a novel idea". It was nice to actually see someone address something that a lot of my classmates (including myself) have addressed time and time again when it comes to designing an effective classroom and instructional design. I would think that the tactics talked about though (routinely meeting with students in small groups, etc) might be hard in a strictly online format. Which makes me wonder how you could even realize that someone has a learning need. Is it obvious as someone who's evaluating that learner?? I suppose a lot of these questions will be addressed when I finally am at the head of the classroom teaching, but it's something to think about - especially with online learning becoming a bigger thing. What I liked about this diagram though was that it seemed to address common things that can be problems for learners - and gave practical and functional solutions.

2. Essential Questions

Up until this point, I never really thought about the idea of effective essential questioning. This course has brought that to light for me. I (at this point) find that essential questions can help a student reach their goals for the course; and help the teacher reach their goals as well. It's almost as if the essential question is a guide - to help get you back on track if you need to make sure you accomplish certain points. I now have a deeper respect for the element of design pertaining to essential questioning - and I believe that they are a good foundational block to good instructional design.

3. The importance of deepening student thinking

Explain, Perspective, Interpret, Empathy, Apply, and self-knowledge. When the text listed out the Performance verbs when it comes to the six facets of understanding I had a connection to that. Using verbs made things connect for me...as I can relate to action in a classroom. And action in a classroom can be many different things - sometimes it's as simple as imagining how you (the student) can take things to the new level. I think at the completion of this course (or close to it) I want to take another look back on these Six Facets and apply them in a more broad sense - especially walking away from this course with a strong understanding of Instructional Design.

Connecting Some Dots...

This weeks readings really seemed to connect some dots for me. I say this because as a student, I didn't always recognize the techniques that were being used to get me to understand information - and yet, I probably never had the need to connect to those techniques. But this week, the readings helped me recognize what I once didn't see...and I now have names to go with the techniques that I have been put through throughout my time as a student. The reading that had me connecting all of the dots was the "Instructional Approaches: A Framework for Professional Practice Saskatchewan Education". And upon reading this article, I found that there are three types of instructional methods that I relate to the most...

1. Discussion

I really connected with the line "Effective Discussions are normally based on material familiar to the students." This relates back to the way I interpret information. I tend to have "light bulbs" go off when I am part of a good group discussion. There are times when I will read material...and *think* that I understand it...and when I am able to talk about what I have read amongst my peers, I tend to find myself understanding the material better and sometimes in a deeper way. It's always interesting to me to be amongst a group of people with very different backgrounds...such as we have at Marlboro...because I really think that different backgrounds improve the value of discussion. The more one has to work from, the more diversity in the way you apply the information you are learning.

2. Visual Aids or Focused Imaging

Having the ability to see something through a visual representation can help pick up the missing pieces when it comes to understanding something. I have a respect for visual aids...whether they be pictures or videos...or simply a concept map of a subject...especially when they help me connect the pieces of a subject together. Focused imaging...or "the process of visualizing an object, event, or situation" is something that I think is beneficial to a student. Sometimes is difficult for me to completely understand something unless I can see myself using it in a situation that's current to me.

3. Hands on Experience

What surprised me was that I didn't see any direct method that related to Hands on Experience in the reading. For me, hands on experience was what helped me get through my preliminary collegiate years in the television studies department at Lyndon. What helped me understand the concepts being presented throughout my first two years as a TVS major was to be hands on with the television cameras I was going to be using not only in years that followed, but in the field as a photographer for a news station. That experience made me that much more comfortable with the things that were thrown at me later in my career.

Hopefully as the few weeks in the semester tick by I will start to see the light at the end of the tunnel (so to speak) when it comes to instructional design. Though I know that instructional design is something that will only perfect itself as I use it more...it's something that I have really started to sink my teeth into...and I think that I'm starting to connect the dots that have been laid out before me.

Metaphors...and Learning...

Jill had a great point this week...so I'm going start with that....

Jill: "My understanding of metaphors and their value in the learning process became clear during my Human Computer Interaction course just last semester (and I'm old!). We explored how metaphors can be used when designing technology to enhance system usability. As a result of that discussion, I was able to apply the concepts to how people learn, and now, to transfer."

What really hit me when she made that comment was how things as simple as metaphors can make an impact on how people learn and apply what they are learning to things they are currently taking part in. Metaphors are something that all of us seem to use on a regular basis (sometimes daily) when we are trying to explain something. And how keen of someone to realize that they can be used on an educational level as well. Metaphors could be a way to make information a lot clearer to students who don't seem to be grasping concepts the way you initially present them. But can you overuse a tool such as a metaphor to get a point across?? I think you could. While a powerful tool, too many metaphors could possibly make a point become sloppy...making it so that someone may grasp a concept at first, and then get confused by another metaphors points.

All of the learning tools we are learning throughout this course seem to have their pluses and minuses. It seems to be up to the instructor to make the choice as to what tool they choose to use. Thus, making the concept of Instructional Design more in depth or complex. It excites me to learn about these different levels, and I'm intrigued by the different tools that keep coming out throughout the readings. I hope that in time I will be able to implement these tools in an effective manner.